A tranquil library filled with books on wooden shelves, offering a warm, inviting atmosphere.

Ruth, by Elizabeth Gaskell

I think I have to add Elizabeth Gaskell’s thoughtful but infuriating novel, Ruth, to my short list of books that I wanted to throw across the room. My angry reaction to this book is different from the one Rufi Thorpe tells us about in the preface to this edition of Gaskell’s 1853 novel. Thorpe remarks that readers in the 1850s were up in arms at Gaskell’s sympathetic portrayal of a girl who was seduced by an older man and had a child out of marriage. I did a little more digging and found a letter from Gaskell to Eliza Fox1 that more than one person actually burned their copy of Ruth. My anger springs from an ending that enraged me as much as Thomas Hardy’s Tess of the d’Urbervilles. I wanted our beleaguered protagonist to finally find some happiness, in spite of all of the people who wanted to punish her for what they saw as her sin.

Ruth Hilton would’ve had a much different life if she had had someone who took the time to teach her how to be less naive about people who show her a bit of affection. After her parents die, Ruth’s surprised and indifferent guardian arranges an apprenticeship for Ruth with a local dressmaker. This dressmaker is more concerned with appearances and profits than her worker’s conditions (a theme we will see Gaskell return to her in next novel, North and South). Happenstance leads Ruth to make the acquaintance of Mr. Bellingham, a privileged young man who is more concerned with having a good time than with consequences. Bellingham develops a relationship with our young protagonist, even though he should know better since he’s from a higher social class and because he’s almost a decade older than the fifteen-year-old Ruth. When Ruth’s employer catches Ruth in Bellingham’s company near a tavern, Ruth is out of a job and out of a home. Bellingham sweeps Ruth away to London, then Wales—perhaps out of guilt, perhaps out of perversity to his social obligations, perhaps because of a bit of affection towards the poor waif.

Whatever Bellingham’s motivation, his actions and failure to marry the now-pregnant Ruth mean that she is utterly ruined. Her meager prospects for the future are gone. Bellingham falls ill with a “brain-fever” while they’re in Wales. The landlady summons Bellingham’s mother and, once more, Ruth is out on her ear and even worse off than before. Thankfully, a kindly preacher rescues Ruth. Mr. Benson and, later, his sister, save Ruth by giving her a cover story as a widow. They provide a home for Ruth and her son, Leonard, for as long as they can. The little found family achieves a measure of happiness until Ruth’s past rears its ugly head.

There are many opportunities for Ruth, Mr. Benson, and other characters to meditate on the morality of Ruth’s affair and the lie that keeps Ruth and Leonard respectable. One character, the rigidly moral Mr. Bradshaw, is a foil for the more thoughtful (and, I would argue, more Christian) attitude of Mr. Benson. Mr. Bradshaw is the kind of hypocrite that infuriates me, in fiction and in real life. He only sees things in black and white—until his own beloved son falls from grace. Ruth’s behavior could (and should) be excused by inexperience and naïveté. Bradshaw’s privileged son turned thief purely from greed. Gaskell’s tale forces its readers to think about what it means to be a Christian. Does it mean adhering to Old Testament rules? Or does it mean endeavoring to act in a Christ-like way?

Even though the ending2 made me want to hurl the book (metaphorically) across the room, Gaskell’s novel might be even more culturally apposite than it was in 1853.

I received a free copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley for review consideration.

  1. The letter was written in early 1853. See page 222-223 of The Letters of Mrs. Gaskell, published by Mandolin in 1997. ↩︎
  2. Readers who are curious about how this book ends can find a full plot summary on Wikipedia. ↩︎

Leave a Reply